Fuel analysis
A testing service and a bunker industry body disagree over whether shale oil blend components caused problems on board ships this year. The dispute shows where routine specification testing of marine fuel stops, and what laboratories and buyers would need to measure to settle it.
Marine fuels can pass routine ISO 8217 testing and still cause trouble once they are on board. That was the central finding of Lloyd’s Register (LR) in its latest fuel quality report.
The first-half 2026 edition of LR’s FOBAS Fuel Insight report was published on Tuesday, 14 July 2026. FOBAS is LR’s fuel testing service.
LR linked operational problems reported in March and April, after bunkering at what it described only as a major hub, to fuels containing Estonian shale oil.
In some cases it estimated the shale oil share at around 10–15 per cent.
Shale oil is an acceptable blend component under ISO 8217. However, LR said higher concentrations can be associated with fuel instability and with problems in filters, separators and fuel pumps.
Murray Kirkwood, fuel specialist consultant at LR, said: “The challenge is no longer simply identifying fuels that fail specification.”
In his view, the distinction that matters is increasingly between fuels that are ‘operationally resilient’ and those that are ‘operationally fragile’.
The issue had surfaced earlier in the year. On Wednesday, 1 April 2026, the testing firm VPS reported on very low sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO) delivered in Singapore in February and March.
Around 90,000 tonnes contained compounds consistent with a stream derived from Estonian shale oil.
VPS identified resorcinol and alkyl benzenediols, high-boiling phenolic compounds, at concentrations of 4,000–13,200 ppm.
VPS also reported acid numbers of 1.98–2.34 mg KOH/g, against an ISO 8217 limit of 2.5 mg KOH/g.
VPS said it had received no reports of problems, and that the vessels it contacted had confirmed no operational issues to date.
It still urged caution. Fuels passing initial checks could later cause sludge, filter and purifier fouling, it warned, and affect the cleanliness of fuel injection equipment.
The bunker industry has pushed back. In late July, the International Bunker Industry Association (IBIA) said its Technical Working Group had reviewed the available information.
It had not established a direct causal relationship between shale oil-related compounds and the problems reported.
IBIA said shale oil-derived hydrocarbons are permitted under ISO 8217, so their presence alone is not evidence of poor quality or non-compliance.
The question, it said, is whether the fuel as delivered meets the standard.
IBIA supported further technical investigation. It also called for more transparency, traceability, quality assurance and information sharing.
The scope of the standard explains why both positions can stand at once. ISO 8217:2024, the current edition, was published in May 2024 and replaced the 2017 edition.
It sets requirements for marine fuels before onboard handling such as storage, settling, centrifuging, filtration and heating.
It covers seven distillate and 14 residual fuel categories, grouped by sulphur and fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) content.
A fuel is therefore judged against its limits as delivered. IBIA’s argument concerns that delivered product. LR’s concerns what happens afterwards, in the treatment plant and the engine.
A fuel can meet every limit at the point of delivery and still behave poorly downstream. The specification was not written to answer that second question.
For laboratories, the dispute separates three questions that are often treated as one.
The first is compliance: does the fuel meet each specified limit? The second is composition: what blend components does it contain, and at what concentration?
The third is behaviour: how will the fuel respond to storage, heating, mixing with other bunkers and centrifuging?
Routine specification testing answers the first. The shale oil cases sit in the second and third.
LR advises operators to place more weight on stability, compatibility and composition. It also recommends combining routine fuel quality monitoring with forensic investigation when problems occur.
VPS recommended enhanced monitoring of the fuel treatment plant and avoiding unnecessary co-mingling of bunkers.
It also advised keeping detailed records, retaining additional samples, tracking stability and acid number trends, and asking suppliers about blend components.
The public evidence remains thin. LR’s press release gives no sample counts or off-specification rates, and the full FOBAS report was not reviewed for this article.
The VPS article names the compounds and concentrations but not the test method or the number of samples. IBIA’s statement, as reported, cites no data.
None of the three sets out a concentration of shale oil-derived compounds at which operational risk begins.
That leaves open questions for fuel testing laboratories, instrument suppliers and buyers.
Should composition screening for non-conventional blend components become routine for residual fuels? And which methods are reliable at the concentrations reported?
Which stability and compatibility tests, if any, predict filter, separator and purifier behaviour on board?
How can a buyer check what a supplier says about the blend components in a delivery?
Until published data answers those questions, a pass under ISO 8217 will mean what it has always meant: the fuel met the specification on delivery, and no more.
PIN 27.5 Oct/Nov 26