Off-spec sulphur in VLSFO: how much sits inside the testing margin?

Sulphur analysis

Off-spec sulphur in VLSFO: how much sits inside the testing margin?

18 Nov, 2026
International Environmental Technology
3 min read

Headline off-specification rates for very low sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO) look alarming.

Read alongside the verification rules, they also show how much of the problem sits in a narrow band where test precision, not fuel quality alone, decides the outcome.

Data published by the West of England P&I Club (West P&I) on Thursday, 14 May 2026, illustrate the point.

Drawing on statistics from Veritas Petroleum Services for VLSFO supplied in the Amsterdam–Rotterdam–Antwerp (ARA) region, the club split sulphur results into three bands.

In April 2026, 40.0 per cent of analysed samples met the 0.50 per cent limit. A further 52.1 per cent fell between 0.50 and 0.53 per cent, and 7.9 per cent exceeded 0.53 per cent.

For May, up to the date of publication, the figures were 76.2, 14.3 and 9.5 per cent respectively.

Over the preceding six months, 34 per cent of samples fell between 0.50 and 0.53 per cent and 6.4 per cent exceeded 0.53 per cent.

The club did not give sample numbers behind those percentages.

Why 0.53 per cent matters

The 0.53 per cent boundary is not arbitrary. The amended fuel oil verification procedure is set out in Appendix VI of MARPOL Annex VI.

Under it, in-use and on-board samples are treated as compliant with the 0.50 per cent limit if the result does not exceed 0.53 per cent.

That figure is the limit plus 0.59R, where R is the reproducibility of the test method.

It reflects the 95 per cent confidence approach set out in ISO 4259, which ISO 8217 references for handling test precision.

The MARPOL delivered sample is handled differently. The average of two results from one laboratory must not exceed 0.50 per cent, with no margin added.

Suppliers are advised to blend below the limit to be confident the product meets it; P&I club Gard has put that target at around 0.47 per cent.

A result between 0.50 and 0.53 per cent is therefore a grey zone. It is above the specification on paper.

But it is within the range where a purchaser, or a port state authority checking an in-use sample, cannot statistically distinguish it from a compliant fuel.

Whether an authority acts on a delivered sample in that band is left to each state’s discretion.

Port-level data from West P&I and Lloyd’s Register

West P&I’s later update covered April to September 2026.

It reportedly put sulphur off-specification rates for VLSFO at 68.6 per cent in Rotterdam and 58.9 per cent in Antwerp, the highest in its dataset.

The same report said sample counts at those ports were substantially smaller than at some other hubs. It did not say whether the figures were shares of all samples or of off-specification cases.

Lloyd’s Register’s FOBAS fuel quality reports point in the same direction without settling the denominator question. Its report for the second half of 2025 was published on Thursday, 12 February 2026.

It recorded a rise in both the frequency and severity of off-specification incidents at several major hubs, with December the worst month of 2025.

High sulphur was among the recurring problems, along with catalytic fines, sediment and water. It also recorded distillate samples with flash points of 47–55°C, below the 60°C minimum set under SOLAS.

Its report for the first half of 2026, published on Tuesday, 14 July 2026, found off-specification cases remained elevated throughout the period. Sulphur exceedances again featured among the most common recurring issues.

Reporting sulphur results near the limit

For laboratories and fuel testing services, the practical lesson is about reporting. A sulphur result of 0.51 per cent and one of 0.58 per cent are both ‘off-spec’ against a 0.50 per cent limit.

They carry very different regulatory and commercial consequences. Statistics that combine them overstate the share of fuel that would fail a verification test, while still signalling a real problem with blending margins.

Clearer reporting would separate results inside and outside the reproducibility band, state the number of samples and identify which sample type each result comes from.

Without that, port-level off-specification rates are a warning sign rather than a measurement buyers can act on.

Latest News

PIN 27.5 Oct/Nov 26

Explore our Digital Edition

Discover the latest news and research

Digital edition

Explore Our Other Sites

Labmate Online
Life science distributor expands into the Czech Republic and strengthens diagnostics capabilities through acquisition
Explore more Arrow
Envirotech Online
Vehicle-based methane detection system passes German suitability test
Explore more Arrow
Pollution Solutions Online
Large-scale liquefied biogas bunkering to become possible in the Port of Gothenburg in 2027
Explore more Arrow
Chromatography Today
High-load peptide purification
Explore more Arrow